Meta-analysis of individual-patient data from EVAR-1, DREAM, OVER and ACE trials comparing outcomes of endovascular or open repair for abdominal aortic aneurysm over 5 years

T. Powell, Janet; Sweeting, Michael; Ulug, Pinar; D Blankensteijn, J; Lederle, F.; Becquemin, J-P; M Greenhalgh, R; M Greenhalgh, R; Beard, Jonathan; Buxton, Martin; Brown, Louise; L. Harris, Peter; T. Powell, Janet; Rose, John; T Russell, I; Sculpher, Mark; G. Thompson, Simon; Lilford, Richard; Bell, Peter; M Greenhalgh, R; C. Whitaker, S.; Poole-Wilson, PA; V Ruckley, C; B. Campbell, William; R. E. Dean, Michael; Ruttley, M.S.T.; C Coles, E; T. Powell, Janet; Halliday, Alison; Julian Gibbs, S.; Brown, Louise; Epstein, David; Sculpher, Mark; G. Thompson, Simon; Hannon, R.J.; C. Johnston, Lynn; W. Bradbury, Andrew; Henderson, Michael; D Parvin, S; Shepherd, David; M. Greenhalgh, Roger; Mitchell, Adam; R. Edwards, P.; Abbott, G.; J Higman, D; Vohra, A.; Ashley, S.; Robottom, C; Wyatt, Mike; Rose, John; J. Byrne, David; Edwards, Richard; P Leiberman, D; H McCarter, D; R. Taylor, Peter; Reidy, John; R Wilkinson, A; F. Ettles, Duncan; E Clason, A; LEEN, G.L.S.; Wilson, N.; Downes, Mark; Walker, Stuart; Lavelle, Janet; Gough, M.J.; McPherson, Simon; J A Scott, D; O Kessell, D; Naylor, Ross; Sayers, R.D.; Fishwick, N.G.; L. Harris, Peter; Gould, Debby; G. Walker, Michael; CHALMERS, NATE; Garnham, A; Collins, Michael; Beard, Jonathan; Gaines, P.A.; Y Ashour, M; Uberoi, Raman; Braithwaite, B.D.; C. Whitaker, Simon; N. Davies, Jonathan; Travis, Simon; Hamilton, George; Platts, Andrew; A Shandall, A; A. Sullivan, Brian; S. Sobeh, Mohammed; Matson, Matthew; Fox, A.D.; Orme, R.; Yusef, W; C. Doyle, Timothy; Horrocks, M; Hardman, John; Blair, Paul; K. Ellis, Peter; A. Morris, Gordon; Odurny, A.; Vohra, Rajiv; Duddy, Martin; Thompson, Matt; M Loosemore, T; Belli, Antonio; Morgan, Robert; Adiseshiah, M; Brookes, Jocelyn; N McCollum, C; Ashleigh, Raymond; Aukett, M.; Baker, Sara; Barbé, Ellis; S. Batson, Naima; Bell, Jocelyn; E. Blundell, John; Boardley, D; Boyes, Simon; Brown, Oliver; Bryce, J.; D. Carmichael, Martin; Chance, Tina; Coleman, Jonathan; Cosgrove, C; Curran, G.; H. Dennison, Thomas; Devine, Carol; Dewhirst, Nikki; Errington, Belinda; Farrell, H; Fisher, Charles; Fulford, Paul; J. Gough, Michael; Graham, Carol; Hooper, Richard; O. Horne, G.; A. Horrocks, L.; Hughes, B; Hutchings, Tim; Ireland, M; Judge, Ciaran; Kelly, Louise; D. Kemp, John; C. Kite, Amy; Kivelä, Milja; Lapworth, Michelle; Lee, Cheong; Linekar, L; Mahmood, Asif; March, Lyn; Ellacuriaga San Martin, Julio; Matharu, Nick; McGuigen, K; Morris-Vincent, P; Murray, Stephen; Marie Murtagh, Ann; Owen, Gareth; Rajiv Neil Ramoutar, Virin; Rippin, Christine; M Rowley, J; Sinclair, Julia; Spencer, Sarah; Taylor, V; Tomlinson, Christopher; Ward, Sue; Wealleans, Vera; R. West, Jason; White, Katie; P. Williams, John; Wilson, L; E. Grobbee, D.; D Blankensteijn, J; Bąk, Aneta; Buth, Jaap; M. T. Pattynama, Peter; L G Verhoeven, E; E van Voorthuisen, A; D Blankensteijn, J; Balm, Ron; Buth, Jaap; W.M. Cuypers, Philippe; E. Grobbee, D.; Prinssen, Monique; R.H.M. van Sambeek, Marc; L G Verhoeven, E; F. Baas, Annette; G. Myriam Hunink, M.; M van Engelshoven, J; J. Jacobs, Michael; A.J.M. de Mol, Bas; Hajo van Bockel, J.; Balm, Ron; A. Reekers, Jim; Tielbeek, Xander; L G Verhoeven, E; Wisselink, Willem; Boekema, N.; Heuveling, L.M.; Sikking, I.; Prinssen, Monique; Balm, Ron; D Blankensteijn, J; Buth, Jaap; W.M. Cuypers, Philippe; R.H.M. van Sambeek, Marc; L G Verhoeven, E; L. de Bruin, Jorg; F. Baas, Annette; D Blankensteijn, J; Prinssen, Monique; Buskens, Erik; Buth, Jacob; V. Tielbeek, Alexander; D Blankensteijn, J; Balm, Ron; A. Reekers, Jim; R.H.M. van Sambeek, Marc; M. T. Pattynama, Peter; L G Verhoeven, E; Jan Prins, Taco; C. van der Ham, Arie; van der Velden, J.J.I.M.; M.M. van Sterkenburg, Steven; ten Haken, G.B.; Bruijninckx, C.M.A.; van Overhagen, Hans; Tutein Nolthenius, R.P.; R. Hendriksz, Tadek; A.W. Teijink, Joep; F. Odink, Henk; de Smet, A.A.E.A.; Vroegindeweij, Dammis; van Loenhout, R.M.M.; Rutten, Matthieu; F. Hamming, Jaap; E. H. Lampmann, L.; Bender, M.H.; Pasmans, Hella; Vahl, A.C.; de Vries, Claire; J. C. Mackaay, A.; van Dortmont, L.M.C.; van der Vliet, A.J.; J. Schultze Kool, Leo; Boomsma, J.H.B.; van Dop, H.R.; de Mol van Otterloo, J.C.A.; de Rooij, T.P.W.; Smits, T.M.; Yılmaz, Ercüment; Wisselink, Willem; van den Berg, F.G.; J T Visser, Michel; van der Linden, E; Willem H. Schurink, Geert; de Haan, Mariëtte; Smeets, H.J.; Stabel, P.; Van Elst, F.; Poniewierski, J; Vermassen, Frank; Lederle, F.; A. Freischlag, Julie; R. Kohler, Ted; Latts, E; Matsumura, Junya; T. Padberg, Frank; C. Kyriakides, Tassos; M. Swanson, Kristi; Guarino, Peter; Peduzzi, Peter; Antonelli, Michele; Cushing, Clinton; A. Davis, Elizabeth; Durant, Lydia; J. Joyner, Susan; Kossack, Alice; C. Kyriakides, Tassos; LeGwin, Mary; A. McBride, V.; P. O’Connor, Thomas; Poulton, Joanne; J. Stratton, Samuel; R. Zellner, Stephen; J. Snodgrass, Amanda; Thornton, J; M. Swanson, Kristi; Haakenson, Clair; T. Stroupe, Kevin; Jonk, Yvonne; W Hallett, J; Hertzer, Norman; Towne, Jonathan; A. Katz, David; Karrison, T.; P. Matts, John; A. Marottoli, Richard; V. Kasl, S.; Mehta, Rina; Feldman, Robert; Farrell, W; Allore, Heather; Perry, Elizabeth; C. Niederman, James; Randall, Fiona; Zeman, Marcin; G. Beckwith, David; J. O’Leary, Timothy; D. Huang, Grant; Latts, E; Bader, M; R. Ketteler, Erika; D Kingsley, D; Marek, John; J. Massen, Richard; Matteson, Brian; D. Pitcher, John; Langsfeld, Mark; D. Corson, John; M. Goff, James; Kasirajan, Karthikeshwar; Paap, Christina; C. Robertson, Diane; A. Salam, Atef; Veeraswamy, Ravi; Milner, Ross; Kasirajan, Karthikeshwar; Guidot, Jane; K. Lal, Brajesh; J. Busuttil, Steven; Lilly, Michael; Braganza, Melita; L. Ellis, Katrina; A. Patterson, Mark; D. Jordan, William; Whitley, David; M. Taylor, Steve; A. Passman, Marc; Kerns, Deanna; Inman, Clive; Poirier, Jennifer; Ebaugh, J; Raffetto, J.D.; Chew, D; Lathi, Subhash; Owens, Christopher; Hickson, Kirsty; H. Dosluoglu, Hasan; Eschberger, Karen; R. Kibbe, Melina; Baraniewski, Henry; Matsumura, Junya; Endo, Masayuki; Busman, Anna; Meadows, Wendy; E. Evans, Mary; S. Giglia, Joseph; El Sayed, Hosam; B. Reed, Amy; Ruf, Murad; A. Ross, Stephanie; Jean-Claude, Jessie; Pinault, Gilles; Kang, Peipei; E White, Nadine; Eiseman, Matthew; Jones, Rhondda; H. Timaran, Carlos; Gregory Modrall, J.; Burress Welborn, M.; J. López, John; Nguyen, Tammy; K.Y. Chacko, John; Granke, Kenneth; G. Vouyouka, Angela; Olgren, Erin; Chand, Prabhat; Allende, Brenda; J. Ranella, Michael; Yales, Claudia; A. Whitehill, Thomas; C. Krupski, William; R. Nehler, Mark; Johnson, Stephen; N. Jones, Darrell; K. Strecker, Pamela; A. Bhola, Michelle; K. Shortell, Cynthia; Gray, John; H. Lawson, Jeffrey; L. McCann, Richard; Sebastian, M; Kistler Tetterton, Jean; Blackwell, Catherine; A. Prinzo, Patricia; Lee, Nathaniel; T. Padberg, Frank; J. Cerveira, Joaquim; K. Lal, Brajesh; W. Zickler, Robert; Hauck, Karen; A. Berceli, Scott; Lee, W.A.; Keith Ozaki, C.; R. Nelson, Peter; S Irwin, A; A. Baum, Richard; Aulivola, Bernadette; E. Rodríguez, Heron; N. Littooy, Fred; Greisler, H.P.; T. O'Sullivan, Mary; Kougias, Panagiotis; H. Lin, Peter; L. Bush, Ruth; Guinn, Gene; F. Bechara, Carlos; Cagiannos, Catherine; Pisimisis, George; R. Barshes, Neal; Pillack, Sherilyn; Guillory, Barbara; F. Cikrit, Dolores; G. Lalka, Stephen; W. Lemmon, Gary; F. Nachreiner, R.; Rusomaroff, Mitzi; OʼBrien, Eoin; J. Cullen, Joseph; J. Hoballah, Jamal; J. Sharp, William; L. McCandless, Jeanne; Beach, Vickie; J. Minion, David; H. Schwarcz, Thomas; Kimbrough, J.; Ashe, Laura; K. Rockich, Anna; Warner-Carpenter, Jill; Moursi, Mohammed; F. Eidt, John; Brock, Susannah; Bianchi, C; Bishop, Veronica; L. Gordon, Ian; M. Fujitani, Roy; M Kubaska, S; Behdad, Mina; Azadegan, R.; Ma Agas, Christine; Zalecki, Kathy; R. Hoch, John; C. Carr, Sandra; W. Acher, Charles; Schwarze, Michaël; Tefera, Girma; W. Mell, Matthew; I. Dunlap, Brett; Rieder, J.; McDouall Stuart, John; S. Weiman, Darryl; Abul-Khoudoud, Omran; Edward Garrett, H.; Walsh, Siún; L. Wilson, Karen; R. Seabrook, Gary; A. Cambria, Robert; R Brown, K; Lewis, Bradley; Framberg, Susan; Kallio, Christa; A. Barke, Roderick; M. Santilli, Steven; C. d’Audiffret, Alexandre; Oberle, Nancy; Proebstle, Catherine; L Johnson, L; R. Jacobowitz, Glenn; S. Cayne, Neal; Rockman, Caron; A. Adelman, Mark; J. Gagne, Paul; N. Nalbandian, Matthew; J. Caropolo, Leah; I. Pipinos, Iraklis; M. Johanning, Jason; G. Lynch, Thomas; DeSpiegelaere, Holly; Purviance, Georgia; Zhou, Wei; L. Dalman, Ronald; Tae Lee, Jung; Safadi, Bassem; M. Coogan, Sheila; M. Wren, Sherry; D. Bahmani, Doghdoo; Maples, Deanna; Thunen, Shawna; A. Golden, Michael; Mitchell, Marc; Fairman, Ron; Reinhardt, Sophia; A. Wilson, Mark; Tzeng, Edith; C Muluk, S; Peterson, Nina; A. Foster, Michael; M. Edwards, James; L. Moneta, Gregory; J. Landry, Gregory; M. Taylor, Lloyd; Yeager, Richard; Cannady, Eleanor; S. Treiman, Gerald; Hatton-Ward, Stephanie; Salabsky, Barbara; Kansal, N; H. Owens, Edward; Estes, Mark; A. Forbes, Betty; Sobotta, Cinda; H. Rapp, Joseph; M. Reilly, Linda; L. Perez, Sandra; Yan, Kun; Sarkar, Rajabrata; Dwyer, Shelley; A. Perez, Sonia; Chong, K; R. Kohler, Ted; S. Hatsukami, Thomas; G. Glickerman, David; E. Sobel, Michael; S. Burdick, Thomas; Pedersen, K; A. Cleary, Patricia; R. Back, Martin; F. Bandyk, Dennis; Johnson, Brad; L. Shames, Murray; Reinhard, Rebecca; C Thomas, S; C. Hunter, Glenn; R. Leon, Lisa; Westerband, Alex; J. Guerra, Robert; Riveros, M; L. Mills, Joseph; Hughes, John; M. Escalante, Andréa; B. Psalms, Shemuel; N. Day, Nancy; Macsata, Robyn; N. Sidawy, Anton; Weiswasser, Jonathan; Arora, Subodh; J. Jasper, Brenda; Dardik, Alan; Gahtan, Vivian; E. Muhs, Bart; E. Sumpio, Bauer; J. Gusberg, Richard; Spector, Myron; Pollak, Jeffrey; Aruny, John; Lowell Kelly, E.; Wong, James; Vasilas, Penny; Joncas, Carmelene; A. Gelabert, Hugh; DeVirgillio, Christian; A. Rigberg, David; R Cole, L; Becquemin, J-P; Marzelle, J.; Becquemin, J-P; Sapoval, Marc; Becquemin, J-P; Favre, J-P; Watelet, J; Lermusiaux, Patrick; Sapoval, Marc; Lepage, Éric; Hémery, F.; Dolbeau, Guillaume; Hawajry, N; Cunin, Patrick; L. Harris, Peter; Stockx, L; Châtellier, Gilles; Mialhe, Claude; Fiessinger, J-N; Pagny, L; Kobeiter, H.; Boissier, Christian; Lacroix, Philippe; Ledru, François; J Pinot, J; Deux, J-F; Tzvetkov, B.; Duvaldestin, P; Watelet, J; Jourdain, Cécile; A. David, Victor; Enouf, D; Ady, Nimrod; Krimi, Amor; Boudjema, N; Jousset, Y.; Enon, B; Blin, V.; Picquet, Jean; Lhoste, Philippe; Thouveny, F.; Borie, H.; Kowarski, S; M. Pernes, J.; Auguste, Mario; Becquemin, J-P; Desgranges, Pascal; Allaire, Éric; Marzelle, J.; Kobeiter, Hicham; Meaulle, P-Y; Chaix, D; Juliae, P; N Fabiani, J; Chevalier, P.; Combes, Myriam; Seguin, Agathe; Belhomme, Denis; Sapoval, Marc; Martin Reyes Baque, Javier; Pellerin, Olivier; Favre, J.-P.; Barral, Xavier; Veyret, C; Watelet, J; Peillon, Christophe; Plissonier, D.; Thomas, P.; Clavier, E; Lermusiaux, Patrick; Martinez, Robert; Bleuet, François; Dupreix, C; Philippe Verhoye, Jean; Langanay, T; Heautot, J.-F.; Koussa, M.; Haulon, Stéphan; Halna, Pascal; Destrieux, Laurence; Lions, Christophe; Wiloteaux, S; Bérégi, Jean-Paul; Bergeron, Patrice; J Pinot, J; Patra, Philippe; Costargent, Alain; Chaillou, P; D'Alicourt, A; Gouëffic, Yann; Cheysson, Émile; Parrot, A.; Garance, P; Demon, A.; Tyazi, A; Pillet, J; Lescalié, F; Tilly, G; Steinmetz, Éric; Favier, Claire; Brenot, R; Krausé, D.; Cercueil, JP; Vahdat, O; Sauer, M.; Soula, Philippe; Querian, A; Garcia, Olivier; Levade, M; Colombier, Daniel; Cardon, J-M; Joyeux, Alexandre; Borrelly, P; Dogas, G; Magnan, P-É; Branchereau, A; Bartoli, J-M; Hassen‐Khodja, Réda; Batt, Michel; Planchard, P-F; Bouillanne, P.-J.; Haudebourg, Pierre; Bayne, Jason; Gouny, Pierre; Badra, Ali; Braesco, J; Nonent, Michel; Lucas, A.; Cardon, Alain; Kerdiles, Y; Rolland, Yves; Kassab, Maria; Brillu, C.; Goubault, F; Tailboux, L; Darrieux, H; Briand, Olivier; N Maillard, J; Varty, K.; Cousins, Claire

doi:10.1002/bjs.10430

Public

Meta-analysis of individual-patient data from EVAR-1, DREAM, OVER and ACE trials comparing outcomes of endovascular or open repair for abdominal aortic aneurysm over 5 years

Published in British journal of surgery • Feb 1, 2017

Authors:

Janet T. Powell

Michael Sweeting

Pinar Ulug

Abstract

BACKGROUND: The erosion of the early mortality advantage of elective endovascular aneurysm repair (EVAR) compared with open repair of abdominal aortic aneurysm remains without a satisfactory explanation. METHODS: An individual-patient data meta-analysis of four multicentre randomized trials of EVAR ...

Subject

Medicine

Abdominal aortic aneurysm

Hazard ratio

Research Assistant

AI chat, annotations, notes & similar papers

Finding related papers...

Discussions

(0)

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts!